The Family of Edward Joseph KEITH and Ann McPHERSON

Dudley KEITH: Only son of Edward Joseph and Ann KEITH


                         ?                  John McPHERSON===v===Mary CAMERON
                         |                                   |
                    Daniel KEITH=============v==========Jane McPHERSON
                                        m:17 Oct 1794
                                             | 
    |----------|----------|----------|-------------|----------|---------|----------|------- ---|
Isabella     Mary       Susan  Edward Joseph   James G.B.   Robert  Thomas D. Frances J.A. Jessica A.
1797-1811  1798-1874  1799-1852  1801-1837     1802-1811  1804-1804  1805-?    1807-1882   1809-1852
    |          |          |          |             |          |         ?          |           |
                                     |
                               m:25 Apr 1825 
                          Ann Boleyn MacPHERSON
                                 1793-1857
             |------------|----------|-----------|
      Frances Jessica Ann Clara  Magdelene    Dudley
         1827-1887    1829-1863  1832-1833   1834-1868
             |            |          |           |----------------|
                                              m1:1860          m2:1864
                                             Mary COOK     Harriet RUSSELL==m:1856===John JONES
                                             1841-1864        1833-1912              1828-1864
                                    |------------|                |            |---------|------|
                                Mary Ellen Edward Joseph     Clara Amelia    Alice     John   William
                                1861-1946    1863-1863        1866-1950    1858-1942 1859-1892  1862-
                                    |            |                |
                                   m:-                          m:1889
                           Arthur Charles LOGAN             Thomas MILROY
                                    |                         1863-1940
                                    |                             |-----------|
                   Arthur Charles Logan KEITH/HAYES          Henry Keith  Dorothy Vera
                                1889-1957                     1890-1910   1895-1981
                                    |                             |           |     
                                  m:1914
                              Gladys McINTYRE
                                 1891-?
          |--------|--------|-------|---------| 
        Arthur  Winifred  Clara    Alma   Dudley Keith
      1915-1915  1916-    1917- 1919-2012 1919-1941
          |        ?        |       |         | 
                          m:1938  m:1943
                        Frederick Donald
                          BROWN   MAHAR   
                            |       |

Edward and Ann married in London on 5 April 1825, sailed from Plymouth on 25 April 1825 and arrived in Sydney in November 1825. They had four children born in Sydney: Frances Jessica, Ann Clara, Magdelene and their only son Dudley.

Dudley was born in Sydney on 23 May 1834.

After his father Edward died on 29 May 1837, his mother Anne and three surviving children were left alone in Sydney with Edward's young sister Jessica. Ann stayed in Sydney for 19 months before returning to London. Daniel died in May 1837, probate was granted by the court on 14 February 1838, but it was not until 20 January 1839 that Ann and family boarded the Roslyn Castle bound for London.

Back in London

In the 1841 census Ann, Frances, Ann and Dudley were back in London living at Camden St, Islington. Ann was working as a school mistress.

1841 census

By 1851 Ann had moved to Chapel St, Clerkenwell. She was aged 58 and was now an "Annuitant" but Dudley was not with her. Dudley is not in the 1851 census as he had returned to Australia in 1849. He had accompanied his aunt Frances (Fanny) and her partner John SHERIDAN when they emigrated to Adelaide, South Australia, arriving there 23 December 1849.


South Australia Gazette, 27 December 1849.

At some time after arriving in Adelaide, Dudley moved to New South Wales as we know he married Mary Ann COOK at Goulburn on 6 May 1860. Dudley was 25 and Mary 19. They moved to Sydney where they had two children: Mary Ellen (born 11 May 1861) and Edward Joseph (born c. March 1863). Son Edward died at 8 months on 4 November 1863. He was buried on 5 November 1863 at Newton St Stephens. Note Dudley's occupation at the time was "messenger".


Newton St Stephens burial register for Edward KEITH in 1863.
Death of Mary KEITH (COOK)

A few months after losing their son Edward, Mary died after a long illness on 16 April 1864, leaving Dudley and one child (Mary Ellen).


Sydney Morning Herald 21 April 1864.

Burial record, Newton St Stephens, Camperdown, Sydney.
Marriage to Harriett RUSSELL

Dudley married Harriet Augusta JONES on 23 December 1864 in Sydney. She was a widow: her maiden name was RUSSELL. (When Dudley died a few years later, the newspaper advised the funeral would leave from the house of William RUSSELL, his brother-in-law: see below).

Who was Harriett JONES née RUSSELL?

Dudley's death announcement tells us his brother-in-law was William RUSSELL. Dudley had two sisters: Frances Jessica who remained in England and Ann Clara who did not marry. Thus William was Harriett's brother.

Harriett and her husband John JONES, together with their three children Alice, John and William had arrived in Sydney on 10 October 1863 onboard the Severn. They were assisted immigrants so most of the costs wer paid for by the New South Wales government. John was a Malster (brewer). He was 37 and Harriet was 29. They were from Great Barr, Shropshire, near Birmingham. Their immigation was sponsored by William RUSSELL, Harriet's brother, who remitted £19 for the costs associated with their voyage.


1863 shipping record for Harriet JONES and family.

1863 immigration deposit record for Harriet JONES and family.

The family were recorded in the 1861 census living near the Malt Shovel Inn, on Newton Road, Great Barr. John was an agricultural labourer.


1861 census record for Harriet JONES and family at Great Barr, near Birmingham.

But less than 3 months after arriving in Sydney, John JONES died on 24 January 1864. He was buried at Newton St Stephens Church on 25 January.


1864 burial for John JONES at Newton St Stephens, Sydney.

John's death left Harriet a widow with three small children. Living nearby and attending the same church was Dudley KEITH who had a dying wife and two small children. Mary KEITH died in April 1864. It is not surprising that Dudley the widower married Harriet the widow later in 1864.

Dudley and Harriett had one child, Clara Amelia who was baptised at Cleveland Street St Paul on 31 December 1865. By this time Dudley was now working as a tobacco manufacturer.

1865 baptism for Clara Amelia KEITH.

Dudley died in Sydney on 16 July 1868, as recorded in the Sydney Morning Herald. He too died of a long and painful illness - kidney failure - and is buried at Rookwood Cemetery plot A/B/352, but there is no headstone.


Sydney Death certificate for Dudley KEITH.

Sydney Morning Herald 17 July 1868.

Sydney Morning Herald 17 July 1868.

The newspaper refers to "a wife and five children". The records only show he had two with Mary COOK (Mary Ellen and Edward but Edward had died in 1863) and one with Harriett (Clara Amelia). Who were the other three children? His wife Harriett had three children from her first marriage to John Jones. All three were alive in 1864.

Death of Harriett

Harriett KEITH died 3 February 1912 at the home of her son-in-law, 502 Unwin Bridge Rd, Tempe, Sydney. Fortunately the newspaper gave the name of the son-in-law as Mr T. MILROY - Thomas MILROY who had married Clara Amelia KEITH in 1889. This connection confirms the relationship between the Harriett who died in 1912 and the KEITH family.


1912 newspaper report for death of Harriett KEITH.

Return to top



The Children of Dudley KEITH

Mary Ellen KEITH 1861-1946

Mary Ellen was born 11 May 1861 in Sydney to Dudley KEITH and his first wife Mary Ann COOK. Mary Ellen was nearly 3 years old when her mother died in 1864 and just over 3 when her father married Harriett JONES/RUSSELL. She was 7 when her father died, leaving her an orphan living with her step-mother Harriett and her three step siblings. Although it is not immediately apparent what happened to Mary Ellen the NSW Archives holds the clue. There is a record for Mary Ellen KEITH being admitted into State Care as an orphan and being admitted to the Protestant Orphan School in Sydney on 31 January 1870. Her admission was just 18 months after her father died - clearly the step-mother was no longer able or willing to look after her.


Protestant Orphan School (Female) in Parramatta, Sydney taken 1870-1875 at the time Mary Ellen was living there.

Protestant Orphan School with teachers and pupils. Mary Ellen is likely to be in this photo.

Protestant Orphan School.

The Protestant Orphan School was first established in 1818 but moved to a new building in 1850. Mary Ellen entered the school in 1870. By the early 1880s the state government had begun a policy of "boarding out" which saw orphans sent to 'respectable' families in regional areas. Financial incentives were offered to families to house, educate and care for the children. It was thought that the cleaner air, greater variety of diet, and reduced exposure to communicable diseases would see orphans fare better than in institutions.

We do not know for certain where or with whom Mary Ellen was boarded but the State care only continued until the child turned 18 years old. At that time children in foster care often stayed with the foster family, taking their name. It is possible that Mary Ellen lived with the HAYES family as she and her son later took that name.

Birth of her son Arthur Charles Logan KEITH

In 1889 Mary Ellen had a son, recorded in the NSW birth records as Arthur Charles Logan KEITH, born 5 December 1889, mother Mary Ellen KEITH, but no father named.


Birth certificate for Arthur Charles Logan KEITH later to become Arthur HAYES.

Who was the father - Arthur Charles LOGAN?

The name "Arthur Charles LOGAN" is unlikely to be a random name chosen by Mary Ellen. It probably indicates the name of the father and that the Logan family took some responsibility for the child and provided some assistance to Mary.

It is possible that the Arthur Charles LOGAN born in 1859 to William Robert LOGAN and Lucy Beckles FREEMAN was the father. William LOGAN was the sub-collector of Customs so was well-regarded in Sydney. His son, Arthur Charles, however, after a promising start in the public service as court clerk and land registrar he was demoted to Clerk of Petty Sessions at Kiama south of Sydney. This relocation brought him into contact with the local Member of Parliament, the Honourable Thomas GARRETT, MP for the Monaro electorate that included Kiama and Wollongong. Before long he had married Thomas Garrett's daughter, freshly divorced from her marriage to George Wilson BIRD (she married BIRD on 10 March 1882 in Sydney and divorced him 27 May 1892). She married Arthur LOGAN 28 May 1892.

The Clerk of Petty Sessions (CPS in the newspapers) at Kiama was one he struggled with - it was a demotion to a rural town and at a much reduced salary. He had debts in Sydney, not the least being for his son Arthur Charles KEITH. His creditors pursued him, threatening to take him to court. In desperation he "borrowed" money from the Crown and so in 1893 he was convicted of embezzling £6 from the Crown (the original charge was for £110 but not all charges were pursued by the magistrate) and sentenced to 2 years in Wollongong Gaol with hard labour. The magistrate was not impressed by his creditors in Sydney who the magistrate claimed had "pressed him unfairly". Arthur in his defence claimed he had a wife and young family to support. In May 1892 he had married the divorcee Monaro BIRD (née GARRETT the daughter of the Member of Parliament for Monaro) the young family were her two children (Marjory BIRD, 1887 and Kathleen BIRD, 1890).

To make matters worse, while in gaol his creditors successfully had him declared bankrupt. It would appear that as soon as he was released from gaol Arthur LOGAN left Australia. Apparently he did not take his new wife (Monaro Sarah GARRETT) with him as she successfully filed for divorce (again!) in Sydney in 1903. She could have saved herself the expense as Arthur Charles LOGAN died in Johannesburg, South Africa on 7 January 1904, aged 44.

Death of Mary Ellen KEITH

Sometime before 1914, Arthur KEITH became Arthur HAYES as he married under that name in 1914. It would appear that Mary Ellen also adopted the HAYES surname. Mary does not appear again in the records until her death on 28 May 1946 in Collingwood. She was recorded as May Ellen HAYES and her father as Dudley KIETH (sic). The informant would ultimately have been her son, as she lived with him from the time he married. Clearly she did not know very much about her father or his family. Earlier records show Dudley was a clerk or messenger. It was her grandfather who was the lawyer - like many family stories it is based on fact but has been distorted over the years.

The newspaper notice mentions she was the grandmother of four (Wilma, Clara, Alma and Dudley). It does not mention Arthur B. who died soon after birth. I presume the Wilma was actually Winifred. Mary was buried at Fawkner Cemetery, Melbourne plot CofE T grave 4799. Also interred in that plot is her grandson Christopher BROWN, who died 25 Sept 1947.

Death notice in The Age 29 May 1946 for Mary Ellen KEITH/HAYES.
1946 death certificate for Mary Ellen KEITH/HAYES.
Marriage of Arthur Charles KEITH/HAYES

Arthur KEITH/HAYES married Gladys Winifred McINTYRE in 1914 in Sydney. They appear to have had five children: the official indexes show two children born to Arthur C. and Gladys W. in Sydney and two more in Melbourne but we know there was also Dudley Keith HAYES as he served in the Australian Army and was killied in Syria in 1941. The war record has his date of birth as 6 April 1919 and his place of birth as North Melbourne.

Name Birth Marriage Date of Death
Arthur B. 1915 Waverley - 1915 Waverley
Winifred Nellie 23 April 1916 Paddington

Clara Philomena 1917 1938: Frederick James BROWN
Alma Portia 1919 Carlton 1943: Donald Leslie MAHAR 6 Sept 2012
Dudley Keith 6 April 1919 - 17 June 1941 Syria

Of their five children

  • Arthur died soon after birth.
  • Winifred Nellie joined the Signals section of the Australian Army on 4 July 1942, being discharged 15 May 1946. She then trained as a nurse at Alfred Hospital Melbourne before going on in 1953 to become a midwife at Royal Paddington Hospital, Sydney (see National Archives of Australia Nurses index 1926-1954).
  • Clara Philomena married Frederick James BROWN in Melbourne in 1938.
  • Alma Portia married Donald Leslie MAHAR in Melbourne in 1943. Alma died in Melbourne 6 Spetember 2012.
  • Dudley Keith was born in Melbourne 6 April 1919. He enlisted in the Australian Army, served with the 2/2 Pioneer Battalion and was killed in Syria on 17 June 1941. He is buried at Damascus Commonwealth Cemetery, Syria.

Return to top


Clara Amelia KEITH 1865-1950

Clara Amelia was born 22 November 1865 and baptised on 31 December 1865 at St Paul, Cleveland St, Sydney.


1865 baptism record for Clara Amelia KEITH.

St Pauls, Cleveland St, Redern, built in 1848.

Clara Amelia married Thomas Henry MILROY at St Paul, Cleveland St on 18 December 1889. Thomas was aged 26, a coachbuilder living at 181 Redfern St, Sydney.


1889 marriage of Clara Amelia KEITH to Thomas MILROY.

Clara and Thomas had two children (Henry Keith MILROY born 1890 died 14 May 1910 at 77 Gerard St, Alexandria, NSW) and Dorothy Vera MILROY, born 1895 in Redfern, died 23 April 1981 at Strathfield, NSW, late of Melbourne). Neither sibling married.

Thomas Henry MILROY died at St George Intermediate Hospital in Sydney, late of 20 Beach St Kogarah, on 29 August 1940. The executrices of his Will were his wife Clara and his daughter Dorothy.


Death notice in the SMH 30 August 1940 for Thomas MILROY.

Probate notice in the SMH 3 October 1940 for Thomas MILROY.

20 Beach St, Kogarah Sydney today.

Clara Amelia MILROY (née KEITH) died at 20 Beach St, Kogarah on 8 July 1950.


Death notice in the SMH 10 July 1950 for Clara Amelia MILROY.

Death certificate for Clara Amelia MILROY.

Return to top


Return to the Keith Family Index Page

Last updated: 7 January 2024