The Goldsworthy Family Of London

Henrietta GOLDSWORTHY (1853-1943)

Henrietta was born at 2 Bathurst St, Paddington on 16 July 1853 and baptised at St James, Paddington on 14 August 1853. She was the second of 14 chidren. She was recorded in the 1861 and 1871 censuses with her parents at 2 Bathurst St. The GOLDSWORTHY family emigrated to Melbourne, Australia in 1873. Henrietta was 19 years old.

 Frederick    Elizabeth Thomas       Sarah
GOLDSWORTHY==v==STONE   DENNIS==v==BREWSTER
             m:                 m:
             |                |
           John            Mary        James       Charlotte
        GOLDSWORTHY===v===DENNIS      BOWCHER===v===DIMBLEBY
         1797-1889  m:1828 1802-1874   1804   m:1828 1803-
                      |                         |
                 John Frederick              Henrietta          John            Jane 
                  GOLDSWORTHY=====v===========BOWCHER         DUNNING====v====WYNHALL
                    1829        m:1851         1832-         1808-1887 m:1829 1808-1883
                                  |                                      |
                              Henrietta                                Alfred           Caroline
                             GOLDSWORTHY===============v===============DUNNING=====v=====MARTIN
                              1853-1943             m2:1878          1845-1886  m1:1871 1845-1873
                                                       |                           |
                                        |--------------|                           |---------------|
                                  Florence Annie     Elsie                    Jane Laura    Herbert Alfred
                                    1879-1958      1882-1954                   1872-1929       1873-1935
                                        |              |                           |               |
                                      m:1908         m:1907                      m:1898          m:1906
                                     Percival        Herbert                     Alfred          Ellen 
                                      NEVILE         MOLLARD                     LEWIS          CLIFFORD
                                    1876-1962      1880-1948                   1869-1949           |
                                        |              |                           |               |
       |----------|----------|----------|              |-------|---------|         |               |
      Roy        Jack       Jill      Keith          John  Maxwell    Nance    Marjorie         Alicia
   1909-1991  1911-1978  1911-1967  1919-1969       1908- 1909-1976 1917-2013  1904-1997       1908-1969 
       |          |          |          |              |      |         |          |               | 
       m:         m:         m:         m:                            m:1942     m:1932 
    Winifred    Isobel     George     Elsie                            James    Geoffrey 
      HILL       ROSS       BOSCI    LUSCOMBE                          COYLE    HOUSTON 
   1910-1998  1924-1997  1907-1957  1918-2000                       1916-1990  1907-1997 
       |          |          |          |                               |          |

In the 1861 and 1871 censuses Henrietta and family were at 2 Bathhurst St, Paddington.


1861: John and Henrietta at 2 Bathhurst St.

1871: the growing family at 2 Bathhurst St

On 19 May 1873 the GOLDSWORTHY family boarded the sailing ship, the MacDuff, bound for Melbourne, where they arrived on 21 August 1873. The ship's manifest lists John aged 44 and Henrietta aged 39 and Henrietta Jnr aged 19.


Passenger list for the MacDuff which departed London for Port Phillip (Melbourne) on 19 May 1873.

Henrietta married Alfred Theodore DUNNING in Melbourne on 21 September 1878. They had two children: Florence Annie (born 1879 in Dunedin) and Elsie (born 1882 in Melbourne).

Who was Alfred Theodore DUNNING? Alfred DUNNING was born in Plymouth, Devon and emigrated to Melbourne with his family. He became fruiterer but decided to try his hand in Dunedin, New Zealand. Once there he married Caroline MARTIN (born in Melbourne) in 1871 and they had two children: Jane Laura May DUNNING born in 1872 and Herbert Alfred DUNNING, born 27 July 1873. In 1873 Alfred bought land in George St and also set about building new premises in Princes St, advertising the sale of his personal items, including his choice canaries. The Princes St site soon became the Hotel Central, at 90-108 Princes St.


Evening Star 7 May 1873

Evening Star 16 August 1873

1874 Burton Bros. photograph of the Hotel Central

1907 photo of Hotel Central, Princes St, Dunedin

According to various sources (e.g. built in Dunedin):

"Alfred Theodore Dunning and Frederick Charles Edward Dunning were English settlers who started out as fruiterers in Princes Street in 1864. Frederick left the partnership in 1871, but did return for a few years later in the decade. In 1874 Alfred was granted a license for the City Dining Rooms, which he opened upstairs in the new building. He established a hotel across the upper floors of both buildings, and from 1878 the establishment was known as Dunning's Central Hotel and Café. The portion above the drapery contained bedrooms, while rooms in the northern part included a dining room, offices, and a large billiard room. Alfred was known for his joviality, uprightness in business, and warm-heartedness, but although he did well in the hotel business he was less successful when he left in 1881 to take up theatrical management. He lost most of his money in opera ventures."

But the remainder of 1873 was not kind to Alfred. On 20 September 1873 his wife died suddenly at their home in Rattray St, Dunedin aged only 28.


Evening Star Dunedin 22 September 1873

Otago Daily Times 23 September 1873

It is not clear what Alfred did after the death of his wife. He remained in Dunedin initially, as he appeared in court in August 1875. But he was back in Melbourne in 1878 where he married Henrietta GOLDSWORTHY on 21 September. They soon returned to Dunedin where they had a child, Florence Annie, born July 1879. By 1881 he was invested in the Queen's Theatre on Princes St where he was fined one shilling for placing an advertising board on the footpath. In May 1881 he sold the Princes St property for £16,000 cash.


Otago Daily Times 4 August 1875.

Otago Daily Times 8 August 1881.

Otago Witness 7 May 1881. Note that one occupant was August Fettling - Alfred's brother-in-law.

It appears that after he lost his money in opera ventures, Alfred and Henrietta returned to Melbourne. In 1882 their second and last child, Elsie, was born. Alfred also bought (or leased) the Earl of Zetland Hotel. But his return to hotel manaegment did not last long either. Alfred Theodore DUNNING died at the Earl of Zetland Hotel on 9 June 1886 "after a long and painful illness". He is buried at the Melbourne General Cemetery.


The Lornette 12 June 1886.

Argus 17 July 1886.
>
Melbourne Punch 8 July 1886.

The DUNNING headstone in Melbourne General Cemetery, plot COE-Comp-W-18-19 (See findagrave.com)
In memory of
Jane
beloved wife of
John DUNNING
who died 19 Aug 1883.
aged 74 yrs.
also their daughters
Rosa Laura STRONG,
died 27 Apr 1878, age 42 yrs
Malvina Jane died 24 Mar 1881, age 33 yrs
and 6 children
who died in England aged from 2 to 4 yrs
ALFRED THEODORE
youngest son of the above
who died 8 Jun 1886, age 41 yrs
also John DUNNING Esq
beloved father of the above
who died 9 Mar 1887
aged 78 yrs
and Frederick DUNNING
beloved husband of
Mary DUNNING
who died 26 Jan 1899, age 60 yrs
At rest.

What happened to Henrietta and her two children after Alfred died?
Henrietta remained in Melbourne, continuing to run the Earl of Zetland Hotel. She lost an appeal against her conviction under trademark laws for putting cheap brandy into Hennessay bottles. She eventually transferred the licence on 21 May 1890 and went into voluntary liquidation on 21 May 1890.


Argus 17 July 1886.

Argus 11 Dec 1888.

The next we know of Henrietta is her establishment of a millinery business at 10 Oxford St, Melbourne with her daughter Elsie (now Mrs Mollard) trading as Spilsted & Co. But this venture went bankrupt and the assets were sold in April 1914.

We know little more abour Henrietta after this. At some point she moved into 237 Dandenong Rd, Windsor, where she died on 11 July 1943, aged almost 90.


Argus 12 July 1943.

Return to top of page



The Children of Henrietta and Alfred DUNNING:

Florence Annie DUNNING (1879-1958)

Florence was born in Dunedin, New Zealand in July 1879. In 1881 the family returned to Melbourne. Florence married Percival Cavendish Lister NEVILE in 1908 in Claremont, Perth, Western Australia. Percival was the son of Cavendish NEVILE and Agnes Mary (or Marie) LIGHT and was born 24 March 1876 in Adelaide WA. Florence and Alfred had four children, all born in Western Australia:

nameBirthDeath
Roy Lister NEVILE 4 Sept 1909, Northam, WA 14 Jan 1991, Porepunkah, Bright, Victoria
Jack Cavendish NEVILE 10 Feb 1911, Northam WA 23 Sept 1978, Ottawa, Canada
Jill Lorraine. NEVILE 1911, Northam, WA 1967, Victoria
Keith Douglas NEVILE 1919, East Coolgardie, WA 8 Feb 1969, Glen Waverley, Victoria

Florence died in Perth on 29 November 1958 and her ashes were scattered at the Karrakatta Crematorium gardens.
Percival Cavendish Lister NEVILE died in Perth on 11 August 1962 his ashes were also scattered at Karrakatta Crematorium.

Of the children:

Roy Lister NEVILE was born 1909. He married Winifred Lotys HILL in 1937 in Perth, WA. Roy died in Porepunkah, Bright, Victoria on 14 January 1991. Winifred died 18 July 1998. Both are commemorated at the Bright Cemetery, Lawn plaque 79.


Cemetery plaque for Roy at Bright, Victoria.

Jack Cavendish NEVILE was born 10 February 1911 in Northam, WA. The records suggest Jack married Isobel Lena McIntye ROSS and they eventually lived in Canada. The Jack NEVILE in the 1956 shipping record was born in Australia. Isobel was born in Scotland on 1 November 1924, although her passport in 1956 was issued in South Africa. I cannot find a marriage for them. Jack was a "consultant" in 1956 and later an "auditor". They had four children. Jack died in Beechwood, Ottawa on 23 September 1978 and Isobel died there on 6 July 1997.


1956 shipping record for the Scythia travelling from Southampton to Quebec.

Ottawa Citizen 25 Sep 1978.

Ottawa Citizen 8 Jul 1997

Jill Lorraine NEVILE was born 1911, twin sister to Jack (of course...Jack & Jill). Jill became a nurse at Perth Hospital. Jill married in WA in 1941, probably to George BOSCI and they had at least one child. George died in Perth in 1957 and Jill died in Victoria in 1967.

Keith Douglas NEVILE was born 1919 at East Coolgardie, WA. He served as an Army officer, being on Christmas Island in 1953 with his wife Elsie Gregson (LUSCOMBE) and their two children. They had married in Perth in 1941. By 1968 they were in Glen Waverley, Melbourne, where Keith died on 8 Feb 1969. Elsie died on 2 October 2000 at the Gold Coast, Queensland.

Return to top of page


Elsie DUNNING (1882-1954)

Elsie was born in Fitzroy, Melbourne in 1882 to Alfred and Henrietta DUNNING. By this time Alfred had given up his attempts at making money from opera and returned to being an innkeeper in Melbourne. Elsie married Herbert Francis MOLLARD on 30 July 1907 at St Mary's Church, Perth. Herbert was a commercial traveller. They moved around Australia and also spent 6 months in Auckland New Zealand, before returning to Melbourne. They had three children: John Claude (b. 28 May 1908), Maxwell Francis (born 18 Dec 1909, died 4 Nov 1976) and Nance (born 1917). Elsie and her mother established a millinery business in Melbourne but it went broke in 1914. There are also court records for Elsie filing for divorce from Herbert in 1926 which were strongly rejected by Alfred. It appears that the case was not pursued further, so a divorce was not granted. The electoral rolls continue for many years afterwards have them both at the same address and Herbert's obituary refers to "husband of Elsie". Elsie died at her mother's home, 237 Dandenong Rd on 9 June 1954.


Argus 10 June 1954.

Herbert died in Ashworth St, Albert Park Melbourne on 11 August 1948.

Return to top of page


Return to John Frederick Goldsworthy page

Return to Goldsworthy Index

Last updated: 21 April 2021